(NEW YORK) — Judge Judy will be ending, but Judge Judy isn’t going anywhere.
Confused? Judy Sheindlin’s announcement Monday that her popular syndicated courtroom show will end production in 2021 sets the stage for her return in a different format even as her old show may not really go anywhere.
The tough-talking former New York family court judge has ruled her television courtroom since 1996 and its popularity made her the highest-paid personality in TV. She announced on Ellen that next season will be her 25th and last making original episodes of Judge Judy.
After that, the 77-year-old mediator will be making a new show — called Judy Justice — that will debut in fall 2021.
“If you’re not tired, you’re not supposed to stop,” Sheindlin told Ellen DeGeneres.
CBS, meanwhile, has made a two-year deal with stations that currently carry Judge Judy to air reruns of the program. Based on 25 years of a regular production schedule, it’s likely there are some 5,000 episodes of the program in CBS’ library, said Bill Carroll, a program consultant and expert in the syndication market.
Currently, most markets air two half-hour episodes of Judge Judy back-to-back on weekdays, and the second one is usually a rerun from a past year. It’s done so seamlessly that many viewers don’t notice it’s an old episode; in fact, ratings for the second half hour are often better, Carroll said. It’s a winner for CBS if the show continues to be successful without the production costs — particularly Sheindlin’s salary — of new material, he said.
“At this point, if I’m CBS I have an asset that I’ve already paid for,” he said. “My only costs are promotion and delivery. That’s money in the bank.”
Sheindlin isn’t saying anything about Judy Justice and its format, whether it’s a talk show or some judging panel. Executives probably don’t want anything that looks too much like Judge Judy.
“Even if it’s not successful, she’s got enough money that it doesn’t matter,” Carroll said. “I don’t see how she loses. I don’t see how CBS loses.”
